A Peculiar Notion

The Very strange Idea of Theistic Evolution

It is no longer a secret that evolutionary theory faces severe evidential problems. As empirical research unfolds, the explanatory deficits of evolution increase.¹ Yet equally important—although not as well recognized—is the fact that the very idea of "theistic evolution" is problematic, especially when considered in light of the Christian tradition.² Indeed, even before an empirical analysis of theistic evolution can be undertaken, one must be clear on the concept itself. And this is where a range of under-appreciated problems immediately emerge, as philosopher of science Stephen Meyer has helpfully pointed out in a recent analysis.³

The main...