Sunday, July 22, 2018 | site map | contact | FSJ

Subscribe to Salvo magazine today! Take a look at an issue online and if you like what you see, SUBSCRIBE at a discounted rate.

You Can Be Part of Salvo By Supporting Its Mission Today

We depend on all our great readers to keep Salvo going!

Follow Salvo online

Join Our Email List
Enter your email below:

Further Reading


Weekly Salvo

September 22, 2016

Does 'A' Mean Excellent Anymore?

Because of "grade inflation" (the common grade at Harvard is 'A'), some teachers have been going back to grading on the curve. But it has problems, too, as considered in this article in the New York Times:

[T]he forced curve suffers from two serious flaws. One: It arbitrarily limits the number of students who can excel. If your forced curve allows for only seven A's, but 10 students have mastered the material, three of them will be unfairly punished. (I've found a huge variation in overall performance among the classes I teach.)

After analyzing grading systems, the economists Pradeep Dubey and John Geanakoplos concluded that a forced grade curve is a disincentive to study. "Absolute grading is better than grading on a curve," they wrote.

The more important argument against grade curves is that they create an atmosphere that's toxic by pitting students against one another. At best, it creates a hypercompetitive culture, and at worst, it sends students the message that the world is a zero-sum game: Your success means my failure.

Of course, "absolute grading" means you have to have absolute standards for what an 'A' grade means. But I this age of relativism and "who's to say what is best?" that might be a hard sell.

In school there should be wrong and right answers, discernible levels of excellence and mediocrity, just as there is in life. Or should be. Granted, sometimes it's a matter of judgment, but the judgment is an attempt to grade against some set standard, not an arbitrary assignment of value to make students feel good about themselves. Or forcing an inferior grade on a good student because he can't be squeezed into the curve's quotas. If the student performs well according to the standard, he should get the right grade and be happy that others got one as well for excellent work. Or are we subtly teaching students that the world really is and should be 'dog eat dog'? We can do better than that!

Related reading from Salvo:

School Deform
How Common Core Promotes Cultural Engineering by Killing the Imagination
by Robin Phillips

Functional Belief
From John Dewey to the Ivory Tower of Babel in Two Easy Steps
by Terrell Clemmons

Sabbath School
On the Emancipation of Frederick Douglass by Means of Liberal Education
by Thomas Jodziewicz

Also, be sure to take a look at the new issue of Salvo!


Subscribe to Salvo today!

If you enjoy Salvo, please consider giving an online donation! Thanks for your continued support.


A Boy's Life: 5 Recommendations for Shielding Our Sons from the Anti-Culture—And Setting Them Towards Manhood by Anthony Esolen

Revolution 101: How the 'New Civics' Is Fomenting Civil Unrest by Terrell Clemmons

Up for Grabs: In Science, When 'Anything Goes,' Everything Goes by Denyse O'Leary

Optimal Optics: Evolutionists Don't Know a Good Eye When They See One by Jonathan Wells


The Darwin Tales: It's Time to Remit Darwinian Storytelling to the Annals of History by Terrell Clemmons

Engendered Confusion: The Chaos of Postmodern Sexuality by Laurie Higgins

Zombie Killer: The "Icons of Evolution" Have Joined the Ranks of the Undead by Denyse O'Leary

My Favorite Zombies: Can We Let Them Rest in Peace? by James M. Kushiner

Eye Openers: Eight Common Factors for Atheists Changing Their Minds About God by Matt Nelson

Tuning Out the Universe: How Naturalism & Post-Fact Science Ignore the Evidence We See by Denyse O'Leary

Deep-Seated Rights: What They Are & Why You Have Them by Steve Jones

Improbably So: Fine-Tuning Is Unlikely, but Unlikely Things Happen All the Time by Tim Barnett

The Long Red Shadow: Mike Shotwell Has a Message for Millennial America by Terrell Clemmons

The Good Life: It's to Know, Serve & Love the Truth, Not the Pursuit of Happiness by James Altena

Taking Polls Apart: Human Complexity Foils Electoral Predictions by Denyse O'Leary

Morality as Story: The False Charity of Modern Journalism by Rebekah Curtis

Can We Talk?: It Is Crucial That We Put Our Minds to Contentious Issues by James M. Kushiner

© 2018 Salvo magazine. Published by The Fellowship of St. James. All rights reserved. Returns, refunds, and privacy policy.